Alternatives to Bankruptcy: What Works, What Doesn’t, and When to Stop Trying

Brian V. Lee

Bankruptcy is not the answer for everyone who cannot pay their bills. I tell people that in consultations every week, and some of them leave without filing.

Here are the alternatives, what each one can realistically do, and the point at which trying them costs you more than filing would.

Can I budget my way out?

Sometimes, and it is the first thing to try.

Write down every expense. Not the round numbers you think you spend, the actual numbers from the last three months of statements. Then cut, starting with anything that is not food, shelter, transportation to work and the medicine you need.

Run the math on what is left. If paying three times the minimum on your cards gets you to zero in two or three years, a budget can work. If it takes ten years, or if there is nothing left to cut and you are still short, the budget is not the problem.

One more thing. If you do not live alone, the budget has to be a household decision. Austerity imposed on a family that did not agree to it rarely lasts.

Can I earn my way out?

A second job, a side business, a raise, selling what you do not need. Any of these helps, and if your trouble is temporary, more income can carry you through it.

The limit is interest. When too much of your income already goes to servicing debt, a second job pays the interest and the balance does not move.

Add up what you pay in interest and fees each month. If that number is close to what a second job would clear, you are working to stand still.

Should I call my creditors?

Yes, before you default, not after. Most creditors have hardship programs: a lower rate for a period, a skipped payment, a reduced minimum. They do not advertise them, and they offer them to people who call.

Keep it short. Tell them what happened and what you can pay. You will tell the same story to a different representative every time you call, which is frustrating, but it beats being sued.

Utilities and service providers are different from debts. Call them for a payment arrangement before service is cut off.

What about debt settlement?

Debt settlement is an agreement with a creditor to accept less than the full balance as payment in full. It works best when you have one or two large debts and a lump sum to offer.

Three cautions. Most creditors will not settle until the account is in default, so your credit takes the hit first. Settled debt above a small threshold is reported to the IRS as forgiven debt and may be taxable income, unless you were insolvent at the time.

And the settlement companies that advertise on the radio take monthly fees for months before they settle anything, and some of my bankruptcy clients came to me after paying them thousands for nothing.

If you want to settle, do it through a lawyer, with the terms in writing before you pay. Here is how settlement works once you have been sued.

What about debt consolidation?

Consolidation replaces several debts with one new loan. It only helps if the new loan has a lower rate or a lower payment, and it only works if you stop using the cards you just paid off.

It also requires good credit or a lender that knows you, which is why it is out of reach for most people who need it. If you are going to try, start with a credit union rather than an online lender.

Watch for the trap: consolidating unsecured credit card debt into a home equity loan turns debt that bankruptcy could erase into debt secured by your house.

What about a credit counseling plan?

A nonprofit credit counseling agency can put you on a debt management plan: one monthly payment, distributed to your creditors, often at reduced interest. The plans usually run three to five years, and the agency’s fee is small.

A plan works if your income covers your living expenses plus the plan payment. It does not reduce principal, and if you miss payments the creditors drop out.

For a lot of people it is a good middle path. For people whose income does not cover the payment, it is a slower road to the same place.

When is bankruptcy the better choice?

When the alternatives would take years and still might not work.

The signs I look for: you are paying only interest and the balances are not moving; you are borrowing from one card to pay another; a creditor has sued you or a garnishment has started; or you have already tried settlement or a counseling plan and fallen off it. At that point every month you spend on an alternative is a month of payments that bankruptcy would have erased.

Chapter 7 eliminates credit cards, medical bills and personal loans in three to six months. Chapter 13 reorganizes what you owe over three to five years and stops a foreclosure or garnishment the day it is filed. Neither one requires you to be broke first, and waiting until you are usually costs you money.

What should I do right now?

Make a list of every debt, with the balance, the rate and the minimum payment, and bring it to a free consultation. I will run the numbers for each option against your actual income, and I will tell you if an alternative fits better than filing.

Call (202) 448-5136. I handle bankruptcy and debt relief in DC, Maryland and Northern Virginia.

Don’t let the decision make itself.

They Called. They're Glad They Did.

Couldn’t have chosen a better attorney! He was extremely down-to-earth, explained everything clearly, and always made himself available whenever I had questions—even after my case was over. He helped me through a difficult financial situation and also helped put me in a better...

Tenisha S.
ll-review-tenisha-s.jpg

Thank you so much, for being an awesome lawyer. You took care of me and my husband when all the lawyer offices that we called did not answer or even seems to care, you stepped in and save the day. You listened to us and you took care of us as if we were family. You listened and...

Sylvia S.
ll-review-sylvia-s.jpg

Choosing Lee Legal to help me file for bankruptcy was the best decision I have made in a long time. Brian explained the entire process and answered every single question I posed. The mountain of building stress due to my situation lifted the second Brian walked me through the...

Craig O.
ll-review-craig-o.jpg

Brian Lee from Lee Legal was an amazing attorney to work with. He took his time, reviewed my documents and we discussed my situation thoroughly. He explained the process and my options as well as gave his recommendation. Not only did he assist, but he ensured that I knew this...

Sharrie S.
ll-review-sharrie-scott.jpg

Brian is hands down the most amazing bankruptcy lawyer out there. he answered all my questions and even supported issues that arose 2 years after discharge Thank you for everything!!!!!!

Traneesha S.
ll-review-traneesha-s.jpg

Mr. Brian Lee made a stressful financial situation much easier to handle. Having a guide who is both deeply knowledgeable and approachable makes a massive difference when you are navigating financial challenges for the first time. THE BEST!!!

Latrese B.
ll-review-latrese.jpg

Search no more! Brian is trustworthy, friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable. Bankruptcy is never an easy decision to make however when it's time you'll need a good lawyer by your side. This is the man to do the job. I had zero hiccups throughout the entire process. Please do...

Terry A.
ll-review-terry-a.png

I was very nervous and scared about going through this process. But Brian was very knowledgeable and helped me through it. I was notified about any and all updates to my case and he was very responsive when I had questions regarding any concerns I had. Although a bit nerve...

Regina L.
ll-review-regina-leng.jpg

I wanted to share my sincere appreciation for Brian and the support he provided during a very difficult time for my grandmother. We were not wealthy, but Brian treated us with genuine kindness and respect, making sure we felt comfortable throughout the entire process. He took the...

Jessica R.
unnamed.png

This is your last stop in your searches for an attorney. After numerous research and interview with many lawyers, I decided to hire attorney Brian Lee. He is extremely knowledgeable, personable, attentive and diligent. He went above and beyond to file my ch 7 bankruptcy and get a...

Zhanna H.
zhanna-h.jpg

Brian provided me with a very detailed analysis about my potential case after our first consultation. He promptly responded to all my complex questions, especially navigating student loans and some tax discussions. He is very professional and experienced at what he does, I would...

Eliane R.
ll-review-eliane-rodriguez.jpg

Schedule Your Free Consultation

Fill out the contact form or call (202) 448-5136 to schedule your free consultation.

Reach Out Today

Your information stays between us. The consultation is free and there's no obligation. I'll call you back the same day.