Top 5 Foreclosure Defenses in Virginia, Maryland and Washington, DC

Brian V. Lee

You may have a defense to your foreclosure. You are not going to get a free house.

Both of those are true, and the homeowners who do best are the ones who understand both from the start. Here are the defenses that still carry weight in DC, Maryland and Virginia, how you raise them in each place, and what they can realistically buy you.

How do I raise a foreclosure defense in DC, Maryland or Virginia?

It depends on where the house is, because the three jurisdictions run foreclosure three different ways.

Washington, DC. Most residential foreclosures go through DC Superior Court. The lender files a complaint, and you raise your defenses in your answer, in the same case. You do not have to start a lawsuit of your own.

Maryland. The lender files an Order to Docket in circuit court, but there is no complaint to answer. You raise defenses by filing a motion to stay or dismiss the sale under Maryland Rule 14-211, and the deadline for that motion is short. Miss it and the sale goes forward.

Virginia. Foreclosure is non-judicial. The trustee sells the house with no court involvement at all, so if you want a judge to hear a defense, you have to sue the lender in circuit court yourself, or file bankruptcy, before the sale date.

Defense 1: Calculation errors

This is the most common defense, and it is the one I check first.

If the servicer failed to credit payments, misapplied escrow, or quoted a reinstatement or payoff figure that does not match its own records, the foreclosure may be premature or the amount demanded may be wrong. Servicer accounting errors happen more than you would expect, especially after a loan has been transferred between servicers.

Pull every statement and every payment record you have. Then compare them to the servicer’s numbers line by line.

Defense 2: Notice failures

DC, Maryland and Virginia each require specific notices before a foreclosure, and each requires a notice of default and intent to accelerate under most mortgages. Maryland adds a Notice of Intent to Foreclose with a mandatory waiting period. Virginia requires written notice of the sale to the owner.

A missing or defective notice can stop a sale. It usually does not stop the next one, once the lender fixes the defect, but it buys time, and time is what most foreclosure defense is about.

Defense 3: Servicing violations

Federal mortgage servicing rules bar a lender from holding a sale while a complete loss mitigation application, received more than 37 days before the sale, is still under review. They also require the servicer to evaluate you for every option it offers and to tell you in writing why you were denied.

A servicer that forecloses in the middle of your modification review has broken that rule. Here is how the modification process works and what the denial letter has to say.

Defense 4: Standing, or “show the note”

The lender foreclosing has to own the loan or act for the owner. During the 2008 crisis, assignment paperwork was sloppy enough that this defense occasionally invalidated a mortgage.

That rarely happens now. Lenders cleaned up their documentation, and courts in all three jurisdictions have seen this argument many times. I still check the chain of title, because gaps still turn up, but I do not build a case around it.

Defense 5: Truth in Lending and predatory lending

Loan origination defenses, such as inaccurate disclosures under the Truth in Lending Act or predatory terms, can give rise to rescission or damages. Most of the loans with those problems were made before 2008 and have long since foreclosed or aged out.

If your loan came from a small local lender and the paperwork looks wrong, raise it with me. Otherwise, do not expect this to be the defense that saves the house.

What can a foreclosure defense actually get me?

Time and leverage. Not a free house.

Several DC Superior Court judges have said that from the bench, and no reputable lawyer will tell you otherwise. What a good-faith defense does is force the lender to deal with you: to correct its numbers, to review your modification properly, to negotiate a short sale or deed in lieu on terms that waive the deficiency, or to accept a Chapter 13 plan that cures the arrears.

Homeowners who litigate in good faith and keep the door open to a compromise get better results than homeowners who dig in on principle. Litigation is expensive. The sooner both sides reach a workable deal, the less it costs you.

What should my objective be?

Decide early. Your defense strategy depends on whether you want to keep the house, leave it on your terms, or buy time to figure out which.

Keep it. Start with a modification if you can afford the mortgage going forward. If the servicer will not cooperate, Chapter 13 stops the sale and lets you cure the arrears over three to five years, and many servicers approve modifications after the plan is confirmed.

Leave it on your terms. If you have equity, sell before the lender’s foreclosure costs eat it. If you do not, a short sale or deed in lieu negotiated with a deficiency waiver beats an auction.

Buy time. A good-faith defense, or a bankruptcy filing, gives you the months you need to decide. Do not signal surrender to the lender early; the further the case goes, the less control you have.

What does a strong defense look like in practice?

Persistence. Miss no deadlines, attend every hearing, respond to every pleading with something substantive, and keep asking the servicer the same question until it answers: what do you need from me to make this work?

That is not the same as hostility. Nothing gets done angry. The homeowners who get modifications and workouts are the ones who stay civil, stay organized and refuse to go away.

What should I do right now?

Call me at (202) 448-5136 with your most recent mortgage statement and whatever notice you received. I will tell you which defenses you have, how to raise them where your house is, and what they can realistically get you.

I handle foreclosure defense in DC Superior Court and the circuit courts of Northern Virginia. I don’t handle Maryland foreclosure cases in circuit court, but a Chapter 13 filed at the Greenbelt courthouse can stop a Maryland sale. The consultation is free.

Don’t wait. Every defense on this list has a deadline.

They Called. They're Glad They Did.

Couldn’t have chosen a better attorney! He was extremely down-to-earth, explained everything clearly, and always made himself available whenever I had questions—even after my case was over. He helped me through a difficult financial situation and also helped put me in a better...

Tenisha S.
ll-review-tenisha-s.jpg

Thank you so much, for being an awesome lawyer. You took care of me and my husband when all the lawyer offices that we called did not answer or even seems to care, you stepped in and save the day. You listened to us and you took care of us as if we were family. You listened and...

Sylvia S.
ll-review-sylvia-s.jpg

Choosing Lee Legal to help me file for bankruptcy was the best decision I have made in a long time. Brian explained the entire process and answered every single question I posed. The mountain of building stress due to my situation lifted the second Brian walked me through the...

Craig O.
ll-review-craig-o.jpg

Brian Lee from Lee Legal was an amazing attorney to work with. He took his time, reviewed my documents and we discussed my situation thoroughly. He explained the process and my options as well as gave his recommendation. Not only did he assist, but he ensured that I knew this...

Sharrie S.
ll-review-sharrie-scott.jpg

Brian is hands down the most amazing bankruptcy lawyer out there. he answered all my questions and even supported issues that arose 2 years after discharge Thank you for everything!!!!!!

Traneesha S.
ll-review-traneesha-s.jpg

Mr. Brian Lee made a stressful financial situation much easier to handle. Having a guide who is both deeply knowledgeable and approachable makes a massive difference when you are navigating financial challenges for the first time. THE BEST!!!

Latrese B.
ll-review-latrese.jpg

Search no more! Brian is trustworthy, friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable. Bankruptcy is never an easy decision to make however when it's time you'll need a good lawyer by your side. This is the man to do the job. I had zero hiccups throughout the entire process. Please do...

Terry A.
ll-review-terry-a.png

I was very nervous and scared about going through this process. But Brian was very knowledgeable and helped me through it. I was notified about any and all updates to my case and he was very responsive when I had questions regarding any concerns I had. Although a bit nerve...

Regina L.
ll-review-regina-leng.jpg

I wanted to share my sincere appreciation for Brian and the support he provided during a very difficult time for my grandmother. We were not wealthy, but Brian treated us with genuine kindness and respect, making sure we felt comfortable throughout the entire process. He took the...

Jessica R.
unnamed.png

This is your last stop in your searches for an attorney. After numerous research and interview with many lawyers, I decided to hire attorney Brian Lee. He is extremely knowledgeable, personable, attentive and diligent. He went above and beyond to file my ch 7 bankruptcy and get a...

Zhanna H.
zhanna-h.jpg

Brian provided me with a very detailed analysis about my potential case after our first consultation. He promptly responded to all my complex questions, especially navigating student loans and some tax discussions. He is very professional and experienced at what he does, I would...

Eliane R.
ll-review-eliane-rodriguez.jpg

Schedule Your Free Consultation

Fill out the contact form or call (202) 448-5136 to schedule your free consultation.

Reach Out Today

Your information stays between us. The consultation is free and there's no obligation. I'll call you back the same day.