Are Student Loans Dischargeable in Bankruptcy? (DC, Maryland and Virginia)

Brian V. Lee

Sometimes. The answer used to be “almost never.” Since late 2022 it has been “it depends on which loans you have and whether you are willing to file a second lawsuit inside your bankruptcy.”

I have handled student loan questions in DC, Maryland and Virginia bankruptcy cases for more than a decade. Here is where the law stands and what a realistic path looks like.

What does the Bankruptcy Code say about student loans?

Section 523(a)(8) of the Bankruptcy Code pulls three kinds of education debt out of the normal discharge:

  1. Loans made, insured or guaranteed by a government unit, or funded by a government unit or nonprofit (federal Direct, FFEL and Perkins loans, and many others).
  2. Obligations to repay funds received as an educational benefit, scholarship or stipend.
  3. Any “qualified education loan” as defined in the tax code, which covers most private student loans.

A debt in one of those boxes survives bankruptcy unless a court finds that repaying it would impose an “undue hardship” on you and your dependents. A debt outside all three is discharged like a credit card.

So the first question is never “can I discharge my student loans.” It is “which box is each loan in.”

What is the undue hardship test?

Congress never defined undue hardship. The courts did.

Bankruptcy courts in DC, Maryland and Virginia sit in the Fourth Circuit, which uses the Brunner test. You have to prove three things:

  • You cannot maintain a minimal standard of living for yourself and your dependents if you repay the loans.
  • Your situation is likely to persist for a significant part of the repayment period.
  • You have made good faith efforts to repay.

The second prong is where cases died for decades. Courts read it to require something close to a certainty of hopelessness, and borrowers with modest incomes and no realistic way to pay were turned away because their situation might improve. That standard chased most lawyers out of even trying.

What changed in 2022?

In November 2022 the Department of Justice and the Department of Education issued joint guidance on how the government responds to undue hardship cases involving federal loans.

Under the guidance, you file the adversary proceeding and complete a standardized attestation about your income, expenses and loan history. The government then applies three tests that track Brunner but with defined benchmarks: present inability to pay, measured against IRS collection standards; future inability to pay, with presumptions for borrowers who are over 65, have a disability, or have been in repayment for ten years or more; and good faith. If you meet them, the government recommends a full or partial discharge rather than litigating.

The Justice Department has reported that most cases filed under the guidance ended in a full or partial discharge. Most borrowers still do not know it exists.

Two limits. The guidance covers federal loans held by the Department of Education and does not bind private lenders. And it is policy, not statute, so I confirm the government’s current position before filing any undue hardship case.

Can private student loans be discharged without an undue hardship finding?

Some can, and this is the part most people miss.

A private loan is protected only if it is a “qualified education loan” under the tax code, meaning it was made solely to pay qualified higher education expenses, capped at the school’s cost of attendance. A private loan that exceeds the cost of attendance, or that paid for something outside it, is not a qualified education loan. It is an ordinary unsecured debt, and it is discharged.

The Second Circuit confirmed in Homaidan v. Sallie Mae (2021) that a private loan is not automatically protected just because a lender calls it a student loan. That decision is not binding in the Fourth Circuit, but it is the leading case on the question.

To use this, you still file an adversary proceeding and ask the court to declare the loan dischargeable. The lender has to show the loan fits an exception.

You have to document what you borrowed, when, and what the school’s published cost of attendance was that year. Lenders do not roll over, but the law is on your side.

What is an adversary proceeding?

A lawsuit inside your bankruptcy case. You file a complaint against the lender in the bankruptcy court, the lender answers, and the judge decides whether the loan is discharged.

It has its own filing fee and its own timeline, and it is the only way to get a student loan discharged. No adversary proceeding, no discharge, no matter how bad your circumstances are.

What happens to student loans in Chapter 13?

They do not go away, but they go quiet.

For three to five years, the automatic stay stops collection and wage garnishment on your student loans. The loans are paid through the plan as general unsecured debt, usually at the same percentage as your credit cards. Interest keeps accruing, so the balance can be larger at the end.

For some borrowers that trade is worth it: years of breathing room while other debt is wiped out, then an income-driven repayment plan afterward. For others it is not.

In Chapter 7, the loans survive the discharge untouched unless you win an adversary proceeding. But Chapter 7 clears the credit cards, medical bills and personal loans around them, which often frees up the money to pay the student loans.

Does it matter whether I file in DC, Maryland or Virginia?

Not for the discharge test. All three sit in the Fourth Circuit and apply Brunner, and the 2022 guidance is national.

It matters for everything around the loans. Each jurisdiction has its own exemptions, its own median income figures for the means test, and its own trustees. Where you file depends on where you live, and I practice in all three.

Is Congress going to fix this?

Bills to restore the discharge have been introduced in Congress for years. As NACBA’s DC chair, I met twice with Congresswoman Eleanor Holmes Norton to push for one of them.

None has passed. Plan around the law as it is, not the law as it should be.

What should I do if my student loans are crushing me?

Gather three things: a list of every loan with the lender and type, your income and expenses for the last six months, and your repayment history. With those I can tell you in one conversation whether you have a federal undue hardship case, a private non-qualified loan argument, or a Chapter 13 strategy.

Call me at (202) 448-5136. The consultation is free, and the answer may be better than you expect.

They Called. They're Glad They Did.

Couldn’t have chosen a better attorney! He was extremely down-to-earth, explained everything clearly, and always made himself available whenever I had questions—even after my case was over. He helped me through a difficult financial situation and also helped put me in a better...

Tenisha S.
ll-review-tenisha-s.jpg

Thank you so much, for being an awesome lawyer. You took care of me and my husband when all the lawyer offices that we called did not answer or even seems to care, you stepped in and save the day. You listened to us and you took care of us as if we were family. You listened and...

Sylvia S.
ll-review-sylvia-s.jpg

Choosing Lee Legal to help me file for bankruptcy was the best decision I have made in a long time. Brian explained the entire process and answered every single question I posed. The mountain of building stress due to my situation lifted the second Brian walked me through the...

Craig O.
ll-review-craig-o.jpg

Brian Lee from Lee Legal was an amazing attorney to work with. He took his time, reviewed my documents and we discussed my situation thoroughly. He explained the process and my options as well as gave his recommendation. Not only did he assist, but he ensured that I knew this...

Sharrie S.
ll-review-sharrie-scott.jpg

Brian is hands down the most amazing bankruptcy lawyer out there. he answered all my questions and even supported issues that arose 2 years after discharge Thank you for everything!!!!!!

Traneesha S.
ll-review-traneesha-s.jpg

Mr. Brian Lee made a stressful financial situation much easier to handle. Having a guide who is both deeply knowledgeable and approachable makes a massive difference when you are navigating financial challenges for the first time. THE BEST!!!

Latrese B.
ll-review-latrese.jpg

Search no more! Brian is trustworthy, friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable. Bankruptcy is never an easy decision to make however when it's time you'll need a good lawyer by your side. This is the man to do the job. I had zero hiccups throughout the entire process. Please do...

Terry A.
ll-review-terry-a.png

I was very nervous and scared about going through this process. But Brian was very knowledgeable and helped me through it. I was notified about any and all updates to my case and he was very responsive when I had questions regarding any concerns I had. Although a bit nerve...

Regina L.
ll-review-regina-leng.jpg

I wanted to share my sincere appreciation for Brian and the support he provided during a very difficult time for my grandmother. We were not wealthy, but Brian treated us with genuine kindness and respect, making sure we felt comfortable throughout the entire process. He took the...

Jessica R.
unnamed.png

This is your last stop in your searches for an attorney. After numerous research and interview with many lawyers, I decided to hire attorney Brian Lee. He is extremely knowledgeable, personable, attentive and diligent. He went above and beyond to file my ch 7 bankruptcy and get a...

Zhanna H.
zhanna-h.jpg

Brian provided me with a very detailed analysis about my potential case after our first consultation. He promptly responded to all my complex questions, especially navigating student loans and some tax discussions. He is very professional and experienced at what he does, I would...

Eliane R.
ll-review-eliane-rodriguez.jpg

Schedule Your Free Consultation

Fill out the contact form or call (202) 448-5136 to schedule your free consultation.

Reach Out Today

Your information stays between us. The consultation is free and there's no obligation. I'll call you back the same day.